Govt rebuts Lancet report on high Covid deaths in India, calls it ‘misinformed’

Spread the love

[ad_1]

The Centre on Friday termed as “speculative and misinformed” a new study which claimed that India’s estimated cumulative excess Covid deaths between January 2020 and December 2021 was around eight times higher than reported.

The Lancet reported on Thursday that although excess mortality rates due to Covid among Indian states are not the highest in the world, because of India’s large population, the country accounted for around 22.3 per cent of global excess deaths as of December 31, 2021.

The documented deaths due to COVID-19 in India over that period was around 489,000, the Lancet said in its paper entitled ‘Estimating excess mortality due to the COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic analysis of COVID-19-related mortality, 2020-21’.

It said India’s estimated cumulative excess deaths due to COVID-19 between the period were the highest in the world at 4.07 million.

The Union Health Ministry reacted strongly to the study and termed it “speculative and misinformed”.

In a statement, the ministry said the study provided estimates of all cause excess mortality for a number of countries based on a mathematical modelling exercise.

The study has concluded that although reported COVID-19 deaths between January 1, 2020, and December 31, 2021, totaled 5.94 million worldwide, but an estimated 18.2 million people died worldwide because of the COVID-19 pandemic (as measured by excess mortality) over that period, it said.

“This is yet another estimate on excess mortality due to COVID-19 by another set of researchers. Mathematical modelling techniques are essentially process of creating a mathematical representation of a real-world scenario to make a prediction.

“Such predictions are founded on certain set of inputs either based on real world scenarios, or approximations of those (which may vary in accuracy according to the technique used) inputs that are not available,” the ministry said.

Often these studies involve taking a relatively small actual sample and extrapolating the result to the entire population, it said.

“While this may achieve near accurate results for a small homogenous country/region, such techniques have failed repeatedly to give reliable results for a large, diverse population.

“The study takes into account different methodologies for different countries and for India, for example, data sources used by this study appears to have been taken from newspaper reports and non-peer reviewed studies,” it said.

The ministry said the methodology strangely adopts data from newspapers at varied intervals to extrapolate (without any scientific basis) for the total period under study.

“The pandemic had multiple surges during the period and varied trajectories across different states (sub-state level also) at any point of time. Hence the methodology used by this study is less than robust,” it said.

The ministry said for states where Civil Registration System was available, reported deaths during the pandemic has been compared with average reported deaths for the same period in the year 2018 and 2019 which doesn’t take into account multiple pandemic management efforts, including lockdown, containment zones, testing and contact tracing, wider dissemination and implementation of clinical management protocols and world’s largest vaccination drive, which form the foundation of pandemic management in the country.

The ministry further clarified that the reporting of deaths is regularly done in a transparent manner and is daily updated in public domain on the website of Union Ministry of Health.

“Even the backlog in Covid mortality data submitted by the states at different times is reconciled in the data of Government of India on a regular basis. Furthermore, there is a financial incentive in India to report Covid deaths as they are entitled to monetary compensation. Hence, the likelihood of under-reporting is less,” it said.

The ministry said it is noted that authors have themselves admitted that ‘Direct measurement would be preferable to modelled excess mortality estimates not based on all-cause mortality data, which are usually more robust, from the locations themselves.’

“Further they have mentioned that as studies from a few selected countries, including the Netherlands and Sweden have suggested, we suspect most of the excess mortality during the pandemic is from COVID-19.

“However, sufficient empirical evidence is absent in most countries. Given the high amount of heterogeneity in epidemiological profiles among countries, it is prudent not to make such strong assumptions before more research on this topic is done,” the ministry said.

The ministry also said that the authors have also accepted that ‘strict lockdown and mediation interventions can lead to negative excess mortality during the pandemic’.

“They have themselves admitted that finally, the development and deployment of SARS-COV-2 vaccines have considerably lowered mortality rates among people who contract the virus and among the general population,” it said.

“It is highlighted that quoting issues as sensitive as death, that too during an ongoing global public health crisis like pandemic COVID-19, should be dealt with facts and with required sensitivity. This type of speculative reporting has potential to create panic in the community, can misguide people and should be avoided,” the ministry said. PTI UZM TDS TDS

[ad_2]

Source link

Tags:

9 thoughts on “Govt rebuts Lancet report on high Covid deaths in India, calls it ‘misinformed’

  1. これで、銀行口座の登録が完了です。 2018年6月より、これまで必須だったクレジットカードの登録が不要、銀行口座のみでアカウントの登録ができるようになりました。 新規登録(無料)はこちら PayPalから送られるメール 必要情報を入力するだけで登録できます。 [通常使うお支払い方法にする]を有効にすると、このお支払い方法が次回購入時に使用されます。 現在、ペイパルからの暗証番号の郵送にお時間が掛かっておりますので、ご利用前のお早目のお手続きをお願いいたします。 日本語表記の本人確認書類しかないが英語表記の登録をしたい場合は、まず日本語表記でアカウント作成されてから本人確認後、英語表記に変更するのがおすすめです。 ・ペイパルをそもそも知らない方もいらっしゃいますので、そういった面では、金銭面をペイパルだけでやり取りするわけにはいきません。ここがサービスとしての限界を感じます。 以下の画面になり「購入や送金をすぐに試すことができますよ」と言ってきますが、ここでは「Not Sure? Add card to use later」を押してクレジットカードの登録に進みます。 ペイパル(PayPal)に事前に登録しておけばそのアカウントで様々な決済サービスを利用することができるようになります。
    https://sierra-wiki.win/index.php?title=オンラインカジノ_ゲーム数_paypal
    ライブカジノハウスは、名前の通りライブカジノに力を入れているオンラインカジノです。ライブカジノのゲームを提供するプロパイダ10社と提携しており、関わっているディーラーの数は500人を超えます。また、他のオンラインカジノでは遊べないような珍しいゲームもライブカジノで取り揃えていたりするので、本格的な雰囲気で多くのゲームを楽しめます。 そして、現在人気急上昇中のオンラインカジノでも変わらず非常に人気があるゲームです。ビデオゲーム様式のオンラインカジノゲームの種類は、大半がスロットゲームで占められていますが、オンラインカジノのライブカジノとなるとルーレットは打って変わってバリエーションがとても豊富です。ルーレットは、やはり実物の盤上でプレイされる方が人気があるようです。 オンラインカジノに使える入金方法はこれだ! さて、外れても半額戻ってくるという内容に、もしかするとプレイヤーにとても有利なルールだと思った方もいるかもしれませんね。しかし残念ながら、実はそうではありません。というのも、ミニルーレットは全体で13マスと目の数が少なく、相対的にハズレの「0」の目が出やすいからです。仮にミニルーレットにこのルールが無かったと仮定すると、そのペイアウト率はダブルゼロルーレットよりもさらに2.5%ほど低い92.31%という値となります。この半額返しのルールは、マス目が少ないミニルーレットの救済ルールのようなものなのです。

  2. House of Fun Slots Free Coins: © 2022 GameHunters.Club You can get Free Coins by collecting them every hour from the game lobby. Free Coins also come with notifications, emails, or gifts from your friends. To get even more freebies, follow House of Fun on Facebook and Instagram. House of Fun gifts make every second spent in the game more enjoyable. So enter the world of House of Fun, investigate all ways to gain prizes, and let the fun and thrills begin. One will receive a welcome bonus for House of Fun, and there are other methods to continue accumulating free coins for House of Fun while you play. You can receive free extra coins to play your favorite slot games when you share with your friends. House of Fun has so many excellent free slots to select that it can be challenging to know which fun casino games to check out first.
    http://hanbiz.apat.biz/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=73000
    An Intending Player who does not satisfy all of the foregoing criteria is not eligible to register an account with OLG.ca or to become a Player. OLG, in its sole discretion, may require additional information or documentation from an Intending Player or Player prior to completing the registration of a Player Account or at any time thereafter, including for the purposes of confirming a Player’s identity or other Player Contact Information and in order to investigate any other suspected breaches of this Agreement (including any suspected fraudulent or dishonest activity). A failure of the Intending Player to satisfy any of the foregoing will constitute a material breach of this Agreement. Jokers Wild: In jokers wild you can substitute the one joker in the pack for another card to improve your hand.

  3. The Essay Map is an interactive graphic organizer that enables students to organize and outline their ideas for an informational, definitional, or descriptive essay. This paragraph will compare and contrast the Paleo and Vegan Diets based on a person’s personal philosophy regarding harming animals and which diet is better for the overall environment and the planet’s health. 4.8: Comparison and Contrast is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and or curated by LibreTexts. Fairy tales are fascinating, and children in lower primary classes generally know the story of common and famous fairy tales. If not, ask your child to read any two fairy tales with the same moral lesson and come up with the similarities and differences between the two tales. This way, they will also enhance their compare and contrast vocabulary.
    https://captainbookmark.com/story15145212/write-my-apa-paper-for-me
    We provide cheap custom written paperss at affordable rates! Thousands of customers trust us our “I Write Essays For Money” service every day and the number keeps growing! Get the help you need right now! Submit your instructions to our writers for free by filling our simple order form! Provide sufficient details and upload all relevant materials to help the writers determine what you need. Like any type of business, there are good and bad paper writing services. While there are many paper writing services that will rip you off by missing deadlines and delivering shoddy products, there are many more that are honestly run and employ first-rate writers. To find the best paper writing service for you, you can search online for reviews to find out which paper writing services are known for honesty, punctuality, and quality. You can then select a paper writing service that meets your needs and your budget. There are numerous paper writing services out there that can help you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *